"Comparative Study of Conventional X-Ray, Digital Imaging and CBCT in the Detection of Approximal Caries in Primary Teeth (In Vivo Study)’’
الكلمات المفتاحية:
Conventional Radiography, Digital Radiography, CBCT, Proximal Caries, Vernier Caliper.
الملخص
The aim of this study: Compare the accuracy of conventional and digital radiography and CBCT in the detecting of approximal caries in primary teeth in-Vivo, assess the accuracy of each of the radiological methods in determining the depth of proximal carious lesion. Considering direct clinical measurement of the proximal lesion extension is the golden standard.
Materials and methods: The study samples consist of (30) primary teeth affected with proximal carious lesion. The sample was divided into three groups according to the radiographic techniques. Samples were undergoing visual examination in addition to visual inspection with dental probe to assess the presence of proximal lesion enable to detect by clinical examination. After taking radiographic images of the samples according to their radiographic groups, subsequent clinical curettage of the whole proximal carious lesion is done and the resulting depth is measured using a Vernier Caliper.The study included six different tests: visual examination, visual inspection with probe, conventional radiographic examination, digital radiographic examination, CBCT radiographic examination and direct clinical measurements with Vernier Caliper.
Results: The study concluded superiority of conventional radiography over both digital imaging and CBCT imaging in detecting proximal carious lesion depth. Also, the three radiographic methods were effective in the diagnosis of proximal caries.
Conclusions: The importance of using conventional radiography for the diagnosis and detection of proximal caries depth on child's primary teeth, as it provides us with accurate diagnostic information that affect in the treatment decision. Also, the use of radiographic diagnosis regardless of its type considered of importance in detecting proximal carious lesions, while we do not recommend the use of CBCT in children's in order to detect proximal caries only.
References
قائمة المراجعREFERENCES :
1. سلطان ,محمد زياد. (2008-2009). "طب أسنان الأطفال". جامعة البعث.
A
2. Abdinian, M., et al. (2017). "Effect of Filtration and Thickness of Cross-Sections of Cone Beam Computed Tomography Images on Detection of Proximal Caries." Journal of dentistry (Tehran, Iran) 14(4): 223-230.
3. Akdeniz, B. G., Gröndahl, H.-G., & Magnusson, B. (2006). Accuracy of Proximal Caries Depth Measurements: Comparison between Limited Cone Beam Computed Tomography, Storage Phosphor and Film Radiography. Caries Research, 40(3), 202–207.
4. Aldawood, F. (2019). "Ability of Caries Detection Methods to Determine Caries Lesion Activity." PhD diss., 2019.
5. Al‐Sane, M., Ricketts, D. N., Mendes, F. M., Altarakemah, Y., Deery, C., Innes, N., & Rollings, S. (2020). Reproducibility of Subtraction Radiography in Monitoring Changes in Approximal Carious Lesions in Children: An In Vivo Study. International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry.in vivo.
6. Arangnnal, P., et al. (2012). "Enamel thickness in primary teeth." Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry 37(2): 177-181.
B
7. Baltacioglu, I. H., & Orhan, K. (2017). Comparison of diagnostic methods for early interproximal caries detection with near-infrared light transillumination: an in vivo study. BMC Oral Health, 17(1).
8. Bijle, Mohammed Nadeem & Chunawala, Yusuf & Bohari, Mariya. (2018). Interrater agreement and reliability assessment of proximal caries detection tools in mixed dentition: An in-vivo study. Quintessence international (Berlin, Germany : 1985). 49. 1-9. 10.3290/j.qi.a40114.
D
9. Dale A, Edwin M, Parks T "Dentistry for child and adolescent" Mobsy(2000)5.
10. Deery C and K.J. Toumba "Diagnosis and prevention of dental caries " Wellbury R, Duggal MS, Hosey MT, 3rd eds pediatric dentistry Oxford Univ press(2005),109.
E
11. Ekstrand, K., et al. (1997). "Reproducibility and accuracy of three methods for assessment of demineralization depth on the occlusal surface: an in vitro examination." Caries research 31(3): 224-231.
F
12. Farman, A. G., et al. (1995). "Computed dental radiography: evaluation of a new charge-coupled device-based intraoral radiographic system." Quintessence International 26(6).
H
13. Haiter-Neto, F., Wenzel, A., & Gotfredsen, E. (2008). Diagnostic accuracy of cone beam computed tomography scans compared with intraoral image modalities for detection of caries lesions. Dentomaxillofacial Radiology, 37(1), 18–22.
14. Haring JI and Howerton LJ. (2006). Dental Radiography: Principles and Techniques. St. Louis, Missouri, W. B. Saunders Company, 2006.
15. Hopcraft, M. S. and M. V. Morgan (2005). "Comparison of radiographic and clinical diagnosis of approximal and occlusal dental caries in a young adult population." Community dentistry and oral epidemiology 33(3): 212-218.
16. Hu, Tingrui & Tan, H & Hong, L & Wang, H. (2000). [Clinical study of direct digital radiography in caries detection].. Hua xi kou qiang yi xue za zhi = Huaxi kouqiang yixue zazhi = West China journal of stomatology. 18. 171-3.
J
17. Jose M, et al. (2008). "Investigation of in vitro dental erosion by optical techniques." Lasers Med Sci 23(3): 319-329.
K
18. Kamburoğlu, K., Kurt, H., Kolsuz, E., Öztaş, B., Tatar, İ., & Çelik, H. H. (2010). Occlusal Caries Depth Measurements Obtained by Five Different Imaging Modalities. Journal of Digital Imaging, 24(5), 804–813.
19. Katzenberg, A. M., & Grauer, A. L. (2018). Biological Anthropology of the Human Skeleton (Third). U.S: John Wiley & Sons.
20. Kayipmaz, S., Sezgin, Ö. S., Saricaoğlu, S. T., & Çan, G. (2011). "An in vitro comparison of diagnostic abilities of conventional radiography, storage phosphor, and cone beam computed tomography to determine occlusal and approximal caries". European Journal of Radiology, 80(2), 478–482.
21. Kooistra, S., J. B. Dennison, P. Yaman, B. A. Burt, and G. W. Taylor. (2005). "Radiographic versus clinical extension of Class II carious lesions using an F-speed film." OPERATIVE DENTISTRY-UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON- 30, no. 6 (2005): 719.
22. Krzyżostaniak, J., et al. (2015). "A comparative study of the diagnostic accuracy of cone beam computed tomography and intraoral radiographic modalities for the detection of noncavitated caries." Clinical oral investigations 19(3): 667-672.
L
23. Langland, O. E. and R. P. Langlais (2002). Princípios do diagnóstico por imagem em odontologia, Santos.
N
24. Naitoh, M., Yuasa, H., Toyama, M., Shiojima, M., Nakamura, M., Ushida, M., … Ariji, E. (1998). Observer agreement in the detection of proximal caries with direct digital intraoral radiography. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology, 85(1), 107–112.
25. Nuvvula S, Bhumireddy JR, Kamatham R, Mallineni SK. (2016). Diagnostic accuracy of direct digital radiography and conventional radiography for proximal caries detection in primary teeth: A systematic review. J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent 2016;34:300-5.
P
26. Pitts, N. B. and P. Rimmer (1992). "An in vivo comparison of radiographic and directly assessed clinical caries status of posterior approximal surfaces in primary and permanent teeth." Caries research 26(2): 146-152.
R
27. Roointan, S., Tavakolian, P., Sivagurunathan, K. S., Floryan, M., Mandelis, A., & Abrams, S. H. (2019). 3D Dental Subsurface Imaging Using Enhanced Truncated Correlation-Photothermal Coherence Tomography. Scientific Reports, 9(1).
28. Ruschel, H. C. and O. Chevitarese (2003). "A comparative study of dentin thickness of primary human molars." J Clin Pediatr Dent 27(3): 277-281.
S
29. Safi, Y., et al. (2015). "Diagnostic accuracy of Cone Beam Computed Tomography, conventional and digital radiographs in detecting interproximal caries." Journal of medicine and life 8(Spec Iss 3): 77-82.
30. Sansare, K., Singh, D., Sontakke, S., Karjodkar, F., Saxena, V., Frydenberg, M., & Wenzel, A. (2014). Should Cavitation in Proximal Surfaces Be Reported in Cone Beam Computed Tomography Examination? Caries Research, 48(3), 208–213.
31. Senel, B., et al. (2010). "Diagnostic accuracy of different imaging modalities in detection of proximal caries." Dento maxillo facial radiology 39(8): 501-511.
32. Subka, S., Rodd, H., Nugent, Z., & Deery, C. (2019). In-vivo validity of proximal caries detection in primary teeth, with histological validation. International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry.
33. Syriopoulos, K., et al. (2000). "Radiographic detection of approximal caries: a comparison of dental films and digital imaging systems." Dentomaxillofac Radiol 29(5): 312-318.
T
34. Twetman, S., Axelsson, S., Dahlén, G., Espelid, I., Mejàre, I., Norlund, A., & Tranæus, S. (2012). Adjunct methods for caries detection: A systematic review of literature. Acta Odontologica Scandinavica, 71(3-4), 388–397.
V
35. Van der Stelt, P. F. (2008). "Better imaging: the advantages of digital radiography." The Journal of the American Dental Association 139: S7-S13.
36. Versteeg, K. H., et al. (1997). "In vivo study of approximal caries depth on storage phosphor plate images compared with dental x-ray film." Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology 84(2): 210-213.
W
37. Wenzel, A. (2006). "A review of dentists' use of digital radiography and caries diagnosis with digital systems." Dentomaxillofacial Radiology 35(5): 307-314.
38. Wenzel, A., Hirsch, E., Christensen, J., Matzen, L. H., Scaf, G., & Frydenberg, M. (2013). Detection of cavitated approximal surfaces using cone beam CT and intraoral receptors. Dentomaxillofacial Radiology, 42(1), 39458105–39458105.
39. Wu, M., et al. (2010). "Web-based training method for interpretation of dental images." Journal of digital imaging 23(4): 493-500.
Z
40. Zero, D. T., et al. (2009). "The Biology, Prevention, Diagnosis and Treatment of Dental Caries: Scientific Advances in the United States." The Journal of the American Dental Association 140: 25S-34S.
41. Zhang, Z., Qu, X., Li, G., Zhang, Z., & Ma, X. (2011). The detection accuracies for proximal caries by cone-beam computerized tomography, film, and phosphor plates. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology, 111(1), 103–108.
1. سلطان ,محمد زياد. (2008-2009). "طب أسنان الأطفال". جامعة البعث.
A
2. Abdinian, M., et al. (2017). "Effect of Filtration and Thickness of Cross-Sections of Cone Beam Computed Tomography Images on Detection of Proximal Caries." Journal of dentistry (Tehran, Iran) 14(4): 223-230.
3. Akdeniz, B. G., Gröndahl, H.-G., & Magnusson, B. (2006). Accuracy of Proximal Caries Depth Measurements: Comparison between Limited Cone Beam Computed Tomography, Storage Phosphor and Film Radiography. Caries Research, 40(3), 202–207.
4. Aldawood, F. (2019). "Ability of Caries Detection Methods to Determine Caries Lesion Activity." PhD diss., 2019.
5. Al‐Sane, M., Ricketts, D. N., Mendes, F. M., Altarakemah, Y., Deery, C., Innes, N., & Rollings, S. (2020). Reproducibility of Subtraction Radiography in Monitoring Changes in Approximal Carious Lesions in Children: An In Vivo Study. International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry.in vivo.
6. Arangnnal, P., et al. (2012). "Enamel thickness in primary teeth." Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry 37(2): 177-181.
B
7. Baltacioglu, I. H., & Orhan, K. (2017). Comparison of diagnostic methods for early interproximal caries detection with near-infrared light transillumination: an in vivo study. BMC Oral Health, 17(1).
8. Bijle, Mohammed Nadeem & Chunawala, Yusuf & Bohari, Mariya. (2018). Interrater agreement and reliability assessment of proximal caries detection tools in mixed dentition: An in-vivo study. Quintessence international (Berlin, Germany : 1985). 49. 1-9. 10.3290/j.qi.a40114.
D
9. Dale A, Edwin M, Parks T "Dentistry for child and adolescent" Mobsy(2000)5.
10. Deery C and K.J. Toumba "Diagnosis and prevention of dental caries " Wellbury R, Duggal MS, Hosey MT, 3rd eds pediatric dentistry Oxford Univ press(2005),109.
E
11. Ekstrand, K., et al. (1997). "Reproducibility and accuracy of three methods for assessment of demineralization depth on the occlusal surface: an in vitro examination." Caries research 31(3): 224-231.
F
12. Farman, A. G., et al. (1995). "Computed dental radiography: evaluation of a new charge-coupled device-based intraoral radiographic system." Quintessence International 26(6).
H
13. Haiter-Neto, F., Wenzel, A., & Gotfredsen, E. (2008). Diagnostic accuracy of cone beam computed tomography scans compared with intraoral image modalities for detection of caries lesions. Dentomaxillofacial Radiology, 37(1), 18–22.
14. Haring JI and Howerton LJ. (2006). Dental Radiography: Principles and Techniques. St. Louis, Missouri, W. B. Saunders Company, 2006.
15. Hopcraft, M. S. and M. V. Morgan (2005). "Comparison of radiographic and clinical diagnosis of approximal and occlusal dental caries in a young adult population." Community dentistry and oral epidemiology 33(3): 212-218.
16. Hu, Tingrui & Tan, H & Hong, L & Wang, H. (2000). [Clinical study of direct digital radiography in caries detection].. Hua xi kou qiang yi xue za zhi = Huaxi kouqiang yixue zazhi = West China journal of stomatology. 18. 171-3.
J
17. Jose M, et al. (2008). "Investigation of in vitro dental erosion by optical techniques." Lasers Med Sci 23(3): 319-329.
K
18. Kamburoğlu, K., Kurt, H., Kolsuz, E., Öztaş, B., Tatar, İ., & Çelik, H. H. (2010). Occlusal Caries Depth Measurements Obtained by Five Different Imaging Modalities. Journal of Digital Imaging, 24(5), 804–813.
19. Katzenberg, A. M., & Grauer, A. L. (2018). Biological Anthropology of the Human Skeleton (Third). U.S: John Wiley & Sons.
20. Kayipmaz, S., Sezgin, Ö. S., Saricaoğlu, S. T., & Çan, G. (2011). "An in vitro comparison of diagnostic abilities of conventional radiography, storage phosphor, and cone beam computed tomography to determine occlusal and approximal caries". European Journal of Radiology, 80(2), 478–482.
21. Kooistra, S., J. B. Dennison, P. Yaman, B. A. Burt, and G. W. Taylor. (2005). "Radiographic versus clinical extension of Class II carious lesions using an F-speed film." OPERATIVE DENTISTRY-UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON- 30, no. 6 (2005): 719.
22. Krzyżostaniak, J., et al. (2015). "A comparative study of the diagnostic accuracy of cone beam computed tomography and intraoral radiographic modalities for the detection of noncavitated caries." Clinical oral investigations 19(3): 667-672.
L
23. Langland, O. E. and R. P. Langlais (2002). Princípios do diagnóstico por imagem em odontologia, Santos.
N
24. Naitoh, M., Yuasa, H., Toyama, M., Shiojima, M., Nakamura, M., Ushida, M., … Ariji, E. (1998). Observer agreement in the detection of proximal caries with direct digital intraoral radiography. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology, 85(1), 107–112.
25. Nuvvula S, Bhumireddy JR, Kamatham R, Mallineni SK. (2016). Diagnostic accuracy of direct digital radiography and conventional radiography for proximal caries detection in primary teeth: A systematic review. J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent 2016;34:300-5.
P
26. Pitts, N. B. and P. Rimmer (1992). "An in vivo comparison of radiographic and directly assessed clinical caries status of posterior approximal surfaces in primary and permanent teeth." Caries research 26(2): 146-152.
R
27. Roointan, S., Tavakolian, P., Sivagurunathan, K. S., Floryan, M., Mandelis, A., & Abrams, S. H. (2019). 3D Dental Subsurface Imaging Using Enhanced Truncated Correlation-Photothermal Coherence Tomography. Scientific Reports, 9(1).
28. Ruschel, H. C. and O. Chevitarese (2003). "A comparative study of dentin thickness of primary human molars." J Clin Pediatr Dent 27(3): 277-281.
S
29. Safi, Y., et al. (2015). "Diagnostic accuracy of Cone Beam Computed Tomography, conventional and digital radiographs in detecting interproximal caries." Journal of medicine and life 8(Spec Iss 3): 77-82.
30. Sansare, K., Singh, D., Sontakke, S., Karjodkar, F., Saxena, V., Frydenberg, M., & Wenzel, A. (2014). Should Cavitation in Proximal Surfaces Be Reported in Cone Beam Computed Tomography Examination? Caries Research, 48(3), 208–213.
31. Senel, B., et al. (2010). "Diagnostic accuracy of different imaging modalities in detection of proximal caries." Dento maxillo facial radiology 39(8): 501-511.
32. Subka, S., Rodd, H., Nugent, Z., & Deery, C. (2019). In-vivo validity of proximal caries detection in primary teeth, with histological validation. International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry.
33. Syriopoulos, K., et al. (2000). "Radiographic detection of approximal caries: a comparison of dental films and digital imaging systems." Dentomaxillofac Radiol 29(5): 312-318.
T
34. Twetman, S., Axelsson, S., Dahlén, G., Espelid, I., Mejàre, I., Norlund, A., & Tranæus, S. (2012). Adjunct methods for caries detection: A systematic review of literature. Acta Odontologica Scandinavica, 71(3-4), 388–397.
V
35. Van der Stelt, P. F. (2008). "Better imaging: the advantages of digital radiography." The Journal of the American Dental Association 139: S7-S13.
36. Versteeg, K. H., et al. (1997). "In vivo study of approximal caries depth on storage phosphor plate images compared with dental x-ray film." Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology 84(2): 210-213.
W
37. Wenzel, A. (2006). "A review of dentists' use of digital radiography and caries diagnosis with digital systems." Dentomaxillofacial Radiology 35(5): 307-314.
38. Wenzel, A., Hirsch, E., Christensen, J., Matzen, L. H., Scaf, G., & Frydenberg, M. (2013). Detection of cavitated approximal surfaces using cone beam CT and intraoral receptors. Dentomaxillofacial Radiology, 42(1), 39458105–39458105.
39. Wu, M., et al. (2010). "Web-based training method for interpretation of dental images." Journal of digital imaging 23(4): 493-500.
Z
40. Zero, D. T., et al. (2009). "The Biology, Prevention, Diagnosis and Treatment of Dental Caries: Scientific Advances in the United States." The Journal of the American Dental Association 140: 25S-34S.
41. Zhang, Z., Qu, X., Li, G., Zhang, Z., & Ma, X. (2011). The detection accuracies for proximal caries by cone-beam computerized tomography, film, and phosphor plates. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology, 111(1), 103–108.
منشور
2020-09-16
How to Cite
ظواهرين., & Sultan, P. M. Z. (2020). "Comparative Study of Conventional X-Ray, Digital Imaging and CBCT in the Detection of Approximal Caries in Primary Teeth (In Vivo Study)’’. Journal of Hama University , 3(6). Retrieved from https://hama-univ.edu.sy/ojs/index.php/huj/article/view/329
القسم
Dentistry
