Comparative study of Molar Distalization with Coil Spring Anchored by Mini Implants and Carrier Device in Patients of Class II Malocclusion
الملخص
The Aim: The current study aimed to compare the rate of speed movement of upper molar Distalization and total treatment time between a group of Coil Spring Anchored by Mini Implants , a Carrier appliance group, and a Distal Jet appliance group in Class II malocclusion patients.
Materials and Methods: 51 patients aged 12-14 with Class II malocclusion were selected for the current study. They were randomly divided into three groups of 17 patients each. The first group received Forsus springs anchored by mini implants, the second group received Carrier appliances from the upper canine to the first upper molar on both sides, and the third group received Distal jet appliances. The transverse movement speed of the upper first molars and the total time for correction were evaluated in all three groups from the start of orthodontic treatment until completion of correction and achieving a Class I relationship.
Results: The mean value of the velocity of distalization movement speed in Group 2 (Carrier) (1.18 and 0.84) was higher compared to Group 1 (Springs) and Group 3 (Distal jet) by a significant difference of 0.001, respectively. Additionally, the mean total retention time in Group 2 (5.48) was for Group 1 and (4.91) for Group 3, with an average velocity of movement around 1.5 in Group 2, while the average total retention time was about 3 months in Group 2, 7 months in Group 3, and 9 months in Group 1.
Conclusions: Processing with the Carrier appliance resulted in faster initial upper molar distalization movement speed and overall distalization time compared to the spring anchored by mini implants group and Distal jet group.
References
2- Proffit W, Henry W, Brent E, David M. Contemporary Orthodontics . 2019 , 193 – 194 – 195 .
3- Nanda, R. and S. Kapila, Current therapy in orthodontics. Orthodontic Journal, 2010. 26(1): p. 97
4- Alogaibi, Y.A.; Al-Fraidi, A.A.; Alhajrasi, M.K.; Alkhathami, S.S.; Hatrom, A.; Afify, A.R. Distalization in Orthodontics: A Review and Case Series. Case Rep. Dent. 2021, 2021, 8843959.
5- Chinitz, Isaac Jay. Orthodontics and Multidisciplinary Treatment Planning: A Survey. Diss. State University of New York at Stony Brook, 2019.
6- Cassetta, Michele, Giulia Brandetti, and Federica Altieri. "Miniscrew-supported distal jet versus conventional distal jet appliance: A pilot study." Journal of Clinical and Experimental Dentistry 11.7 (2019): e650
7- Bolla, E., F. Muratore, A. Carano, and S.J. Bowman, Evaluation of maxillary molar distalization with the distal jet: a comparison with other contemporary methods. The angle orthodontist, 2002. 72(5): p. 481-494.
8- Sarul M, Minch L, Park HS, Antoszewska-Smith J. Effect of the length of orthodontic mini-screw implants on their long-term stability: a prospective study. Angle Orthod. 2015 Jan;85(1):33-8. doi: 10.2319/112113-857.1. PMID: 24745630; PMCID: PMC8634807.
9-Gurgel Jde A, Pinzan-Vercelino CR, Bramante FS, Rivera AP. Distalization of maxillary molars using a lever arm and mini-implant. Orthodontics (Chic.). 2013;14(1):e140-9. doi: 10.11607/ortho.604. PMID: 23646324.
10- Areepong D, Kim KB, Oliver DR, Ueno H. The Class II Carriere Motion appliance. Angle Orthod. 2020 Jul 1;90(4):491-499. doi: 10.2319/080919-523.1. PMID: 33378493; PMCID: PMC8028468.
11- Johannessen L, Keilig L, Reimann S, Jäger A, Bourauel C. First order couples induced by nickel-titanium archwires featuring an electrochemically refined surface during simulated rotation of teeth. J Orofac Orthop. 2013 Mar;74(2):153-64. doi: 10.1007/s00056-012-0133-9. Epub 2013 Mar 8. PMID: 23467733.
12- Albraizat, Bilal Abdelhafiz. The Effects of Intraoral Molar Distalization Appliances: A Meta Analysis. MS thesis. Marmara Universitesi (Turkey), 2006.
13- Kilkis, Dogan, et al. "Unilateral maxillary molar distalization with zygoma-gear appliance." American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics 142.2 (2012): e1-e7.
14- Kalpakuri, R., Pisarla, M., Kala, T., Sachin, J., Kumar, B., & Kumar, B. P. (2016). 3D Evaluation of Distalization of Maxillary First Permanent Molar Using Mini Implants: A Finite Element Study. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences (ISSN: 2581-4893), 5(10).
15- Hashem AS. Effect of second molar eruption on efficiency of maxillary first molar distalization using Carriere distalizer appliance. Dental Press J Orthod. 2021 Aug 27;26(4):e2119146. doi: 10.1590/2177-6709.26.4.e2119146.oar. PMID: 34468560; PMCID: PMC8405137.
16- Schmid-Herrmann, Carmen Ulrike, et al. "Retrospective investigation of the 3D effects of the Carriere Motion 3D appliance using model and cephalometric superimposition." Clinical Oral Investigations 27.2 (2023): 631-643.
